Skip to content
Contact
Spruce and aspen covered ridge with a small grassy meadow and hazy Colorado peaks beyond

Colorado elk unit · GMU 74

Hermosa · NW of Durango

Steep, ~86%-public San Juan backcountry above Durango — an OTC bull tag in big wilderness country.

About GMU 74

Colorado Game Management Unit 74 sits in Southern San Juans, spanning San Juan county near Durango, Silverton, Bayfield, Hermosa. The terrain runs from 6,000 – 13,000 ft. The primary big game are Rocky Mountain Elk, Mule Deer.

Sage, oakbrush, and piñon foothills above Durango climb through steep aspen and spruce-fir to alpine rock and tundra toward Silverton. Steep, remote public country with roaded fringes.

Where the unit is

GMU 74 is bounded on the north by Ouray-San Juan Co. line; on the east by San Juan-Hinsdale Co. line and Animas River; on the south by U.S. 160; on the west by Montezuma-La Plata Co. line, Dolores-San Juan Co. line, San Miguel-San Juan Co. line and Ouray-San Juan Co. line.

Boundary wording is CPW 2024 Big Game brochure’s, with the compass abbreviations spelled out. These are the exact unit boundaries; the maps in the brochure are approximate, and boundaries can change year to year — confirm in the current brochure before you hunt.

Elk success rates

Published by Colorado Parks and Wildlife in the CPW 2024 Elk Harvest Estimates for the 2024 season — the percentage of surveyed hunters who harvested an elk. Success swings with weather and pressure year to year; this is the most recent published data.

SeasonSuccessHunters
Archery18%501
Muzzleloader32%162
1st rifle29%256
2nd rifle20%370
3rd rifle16%205
4th rifle17% *42
Private-land-only30% *16
All seasons21%1,537

* Fewer than 50 surveyed hunters — CPW’s estimate for that season carries a wide confidence interval. Read it as a direction, not a number.

Mule deer success rates

From CPW’s CPW 2024 Deer Harvest Estimates for the 2024 season. Colorado deer licenses are limited — every one of these seasons is a draw tag — so these rates describe hunters who already drew, not your odds of hunting here. The late-season and private-land-only lines are the ones worth staring at: late rifle hunts overlap the November rut, which is why they draw hardest.

SeasonSuccessHunters
Archery36%79
Muzzleloader45%71
2nd rifle36%80
3rd rifle36% *41
High-country rifle83% *27
Early & late83% *27
All seasons43%304

* Fewer than 50 surveyed hunters — CPW’s estimate for that season carries a wide confidence interval. Read it as a direction, not a number.

Three seasons, not one

A single year says what happened; three say which way a unit is going. These are CPW’s unit-wide success figures from CPW Colorado Elk and Deer Harvest Estimates, 2022–2024 — the same all-seasons line as the tables above, for each year CPW has published per-unit numbers.

GMU 74 unit-wide success by year, elk and mule deer
SeasonElkMule deer
202221% (1,559)33% (312)
202317% (1,635)33% (326)
202421% (1,537)43% (304)

Success across all seasons and all manners of take, with CPW’s surveyed hunter count in brackets.

  • Elk success held steady — 21% in 2022, 21% in 2024.
  • Mule deer success rose 10 points — 33% in 2022, 43% in 2024.

Three seasons is a short record. Weather, licence allocation, drought and fire can each move a unit several points in a year, and a unit whose surveyed hunter count jumped or collapsed between years is not measuring quite the same thing twice.

Over the counter, or draw?

Bull elk is over the counter here for the 2nd and 3rd rifle seasons. You can buy that tag without drawing. The 1st and 4th rifle seasons and the antlerless tags are limited and go through the draw.

Worked out from two CPW sources rather than quoted from one: which hunt codes ran in the 2026 draw, checked against which seasons the harvest estimates record hunters in. A season with hunters but no draw code is an over-the-counter season. Archery and muzzleloader follow different rules, and structures change yearly — confirm the current hunt codes with CPW before you buy.

What it took to draw

From CPW’s 2026 primary draw report — the preference-point level at which each elk licence ran out. 1,372 hunters put a GMU 74 hunt code first on their application, across 15 codes.

Drawn out at (2026)ResidentNonresident
Bull / either-sex0 points0 points
All elk codes in the unit0–2 points0–4 points

A range spans the unit’s hunt codes: the antlerless tags sit at the bottom, the hardest bull season at the top. Point requirements move every year with quotas and applicant numbers, so read this as the 2026 result rather than a forecast, and check the current CPW draw recap before you apply.

What it took to draw

From CPW’s 2026 primary draw report — the preference-point level at which each deer licence ran out. 874 hunters put a GMU 74 hunt code first on their application, across 8 codes.

Drawn out at (2026)ResidentNonresident
Buck / either-sex0–5 points0–16 points
All deer codes in the unit0–5 points0–16 points

A range spans the unit’s hunt codes: the antlerless tags sit at the bottom, the hardest bull season at the top. Point requirements move every year with quotas and applicant numbers, so read this as the 2026 result rather than a forecast, and check the current CPW draw recap before you apply.

Tags & draw odds

Tag type: OTC bull (2nd & 3rd rifle).

OTC bull for 2nd & 3rd rifle (no points) — unchanged for 2026 (only the Gunnison Basin lost OTC). 1st & 4th rifle bull are limited draw; nonresident archery is draw-only (since 2025); muzzleloader is limited draw. Verify current-year status with CPW.

Access & crowding

Forest roads off US 550 and the Hermosa Creek corridor reach the lower country; the high Wilderness is foot or horseback. Steep public ground throughout.

A big, public OTC unit close to Durango, so the road-accessible country gets pressure; the Wilderness and high basins thin it out.

Who GMU 74 is for

Classic San Juan high country on an OTC tag — honest low-20s success, with elk holding high and in the timber. A fit-hunter's public-land unit, not a managed-trophy tag.

In a line: The fit DIY hunter who wants a high, public, OTC San Juan tag a short drive from Durango.

Recent changes: Unaffected by the 2026 OTC changes — remains OTC bull for 2nd/3rd rifle. Nonresident OTC archery ended statewide in 2025.

GMU 74 vs GMU 59

GMU 59 is the unit Elk Glade guides, on the south slope of Pikes Peak. Both columns are Colorado Parks and Wildlife’s unit-wide 2024 estimates — every hunter in the unit, public and private, guided and DIY — so they compare like for like.

CPW 2024GMU 74GMU 59
Elk success, all seasons21%19%
Mule deer success, all seasons43%32%
Private-land-only elk success30%51%
Guided huntsNot usElk Glade

On paper GMU 74 posts the better unit-wide elk number. That is worth knowing — but unit-wide success is what the average tag holder does on country they may be seeing for the first time, and the hardest-to-draw units post the highest rates precisely because almost nobody holds a tag. Over the last five seasons 25–50% of Elk Glade’s guided elk hunters filled their tag, all weapons, and 60–90% got an opportunity at an elk. That is a different measurement from the table above and is our own figure, not CPW’s.

The GMU 59 unit profile →
Guided hunts in GMU 59 →

Data sources: elk success rates from CPW Colorado Elk Harvest Estimates (year labeled above). Public-land percentages are approximate. Draw point requirements shift every year and are described as ranges only — always verify the current-year figures in the CPW big game brochure and draw recap before applying.

Plan a hunt

Need help with the 74draw, or want a 59 slot if it doesn’t come through?

Send us a note with what tag you’re applying for and your dates — we’ll walk through the draw strategy and let you know what’s open at Elk Glade.